If the final cut is not to be considered "floyd enough" momentary lapse certainly can't either. I don't really think much of the post roger work as being floyd. I own both of the post waters albums and appreciate them on a musical level but not in conjunction with the other albums. i'll probably get some serious bite backs for this but 'Piper' is the same way. Its very Good in its own right but I'm not sure if I would have too much interest in The Pink Floyd had syd stayed in the driver's seat.

__________________
We don't know what the hell it is, except that it's very large and it has a purpose.
-Dr. Floyd, 2010