| Re: Did the Band need roger waters Waters WAS Floyd from the time when Barrett left through The Final Cut. He provided the bulk of the songwriting, with Gilmour and Wright relegated to provifing the occasional track here and there, and co-writing with Gilmour on occasion. Gilmour provided plenty of those guitar riffs we know and love, and Wright did well with keyboard melodies, but Waters did the bulk of the songwriting and virtually all of the lyrics.
__________________ You're nearly a laugh but you're really a cry... |