Did Dave sing Corporal Clegg? Okay, yeah, I can see that. It must have been Syd doing the "in 1944" little bits in-between verses though unless Gilmour used to do acid too and no one told me. LOL

Anyhow... back on topic. Money is excellent on DSOTM. It's decent on COGDS. But as far as live goes... it's pretty much shit. The live versions completely destroy the edge of the blazingly rockin' guitar solo in the middle by adding a regae-esque jam session. Not my cup of tea. Actually, I believe that all DSOTM and Wall material can't be done justice without Roger, sorry Dave. Rog did the DSOTM stuff correctly on In The Flesh (although I wish Roger sang more of his own songs himself, then again Welcome to the Machine really proved that his 56 year old voice could still hit that high G). They did it back in 73 but the Floyd nowadays just make it sound like it's off MLOR -- and it doesn't work.