well I never saw Roger Live, So I can't compare him to the Pulse Performance.However, Musically, I prefer Momentary Lapse of reason over Amused to death. But keep attention to what I wrote - MUSICALLY! Problem is, the music on Amused to Death bored me so much, I never got to get deep into the lyrics...
Still, My Favfourite PF era is 1968-1975, and that is when both Waters & Gilmour are around.
The only song I don't Like on Saucerful of secrets is Jugband Blues...

__________________
Emily Tries ,But Misunderstands,
But the Sun Is Eclipsed By the Moon!
So Shine On!