Quote:
Originally posted by Botley
The Final Cut....If anyone but Roger was singing, it wouldn't at all have sounded out of place |
I agree. Roger has a great voice -- hell, he has many great voices. But too much of one voice can become a little, well, let's just say that there needs to be more than one person singing on a Floyd record.
To me, Pink Floyd has never been one distinct voice, but many different voices. That is one of the negative points of The Final Cut -- it's all Roger. Just as A Momentary Lapse is all David.
I think The Final Cut may have done better with a little help from David Gilmour on the vocals -- and a couple more guitar solos, geeez.