its like asking how do u like to travel, by car or horse?

The guys are soo different, that the band ditched syd.

One is writing psychodelic songs about scarlet tunics, crossdressers, and scarecrows. The other is writing about how messed up the world is and how he misses his dad.

The two are on total different sides of the universe. So its tough to compare.

People of todays generation might think that barretts songs are dumb. I think they rule! And obviously the suscess of Pink Floyd speaks for Waters.

So it should be concluded that both are good.