Quote:
| Originally Posted by doctor doctor What about the final cut and the wall which were practically solo albums for waters except fo a few solos on final cut and a few co written tracks w/ gilmour on the wall. In piper half of the tracks were collaborations with the other band members so i would say that for a short period of time waters was in fact pink floyd more than barret ever was. |
The very fact that you say they were practically solo albums proves my point of him leading the band with very little input from other members. That doesn't make him Mr. Pink Floyd that makes him Rog with special guest. That the barrett tracks had collaborations shows the band were more together, but I don't think that anybody could honestly say that Syd wasn't the main man.