In The Flesch is a great live album, the DVD is one of the best Floyd-related material which has been released, but SOYCD is the worst track. The guitar part by Doyle Bramall is awful and the saxophone is missing. But Jon Carin's lap steel guitar is cool.

I think the original is best, but the Pulse version is very nice. I actually like Dave's vocals and his guitar sound is awesome, but the percussion is a little bit annoying.

BTW, what do you guys think about the "In concert" versions of SOYCD?