Originally Posted by Dark Guitarist

I have to agree with them to a point. I do think he had a significant contribution, espesially since the lyrics are all his. However, I saw Roger and Dave both on tour in '06 and that's where I see their point. Seeing Dave and Ric in NYC was like seeing Pink Floyd, since Dave is the voice and guitar, and Rick wrote a lot of the music for DSOTM. Seeing Roger a few months later was a little dissapointing because it just didn't come close to sounding like the Floyd. Roger wrote the words, but Gilmour and Wright were the music of DSOTM.