| Re: How Do You...? [read] You say people cheered for Roger everynight at Floyd shows? No way, people want to hear Dave's guitar and voice. All Roger ever did was write lyrics and bad songs, only to be made better by Dave. Animals and the Wall are not Roger's solo albums, its just that he wrote the lyrics before anyone could write music, and so he took credit, Dave says all the time that all the music for The Wall and Animals was mostly his work.
And in my humble opinion, The Division Bell is a great album. All the music for the album was writen by Wright and/or Gilmour, besides Take It Back, which was co written by Bob Ezrin. But thats more than the wall which had two songs written by outside members, The Trial, and Is There Anybody Out There, which was not written by Roger, but by Bob Ezrin. |