Second dissenting voice, I'm afraid.
I'm a Gilmour fan - GW#1 gets it in one - and I'm a Waters fan, and a Rick and Nick fan. That's MY optimum Floyd recipe and anything besides is, to me, small beer. I need BIG beer.

Boys on Film: "Hated it."
p.s. I certainly can agree there are moments in TDB and AMLOR harking back to a Floydian past, of course, as well as new moments of musical ability. But for me, no. Not Pink Floyd.