i agree with you terminalfrost, gilmour is my favorite guitar player of all time. Even though he's not as fast and technical as others, Knowone does or ever will sound like him, he's got a style that cant be copied.
If anything, i think they should do one last and final tour someday, a farewell tour, w/t or without waters. It would be nice to have him, but would be kinda weird seeing him up there playing songs like "sorrow", and "learning to fly". It would definetly be different. But i just hope ill get the chance to see them live once,before i die. Whenther or not it'll happen is a different story