I really don't think all this arguing is necessary. RW is good, no doubt about that, but who wants to listen to his complaining all the time? It does wear a bit thin, so I'm not surprised that Dave and Nick couldn't stand him later.

AMLOR and TDB are good in their own ways so I don't see why they are constantly bashed. Just because they don't sound 'Floyd' enough doesn't mean that they aren't Floyd.

I think I agree:

ALL FLOYD IS GOOD

even if not to the standards set by their earlier music.