The Wall - Disc 1 or 2?

Well, I like the title. It was a bit dissapointing when I heard the song. I like to write reviews so I'll write another one if you want/.
(It's fun)
beatleskid99@yahoo.com

__________________
Vote Byron For Moderator

Disk one for me.

It catalogues musically a descent into depression / madness / whatever like nothing I've ever heard before (and in particular the versions on ITAOT are BRILLIANT in this respect).

The second disk (now that he's arrived at depression/madness/whatever) doesn't really become the emotional rollercoaster that it could have been. Although, as many before have said, it does contain some of the best Pink Floyd tunes ever written.

__________________
Only the very safe,
Can talk about wrong and right.
Of those that are forced to choose,
There's some who will choose to fight.

I like both, actually.

I would probably go for disc 2 - its got more substance, and of course it has CN, Run Like Hell and waiting for the worms.

__________________
And if you're taking your girlfriend out tonight,
You better park the car well out of sight.
'Cause if they catch you in the back seat,
Trying to pick her lock,
They're gonna send you back to Mother,
In a cardboard box.

Wow, I have no idea how you came up with that....first off one of the best transitions between songs on the CD is "the thin ice" and "Another Brick pt1" it's so key.....your list seems to jump around alot.....i agree about some songs being taken out though cus they're unnessecary, Don't get me wrong, i think the album is great as it is and hands down their best one, but one can't help wanna perfect something so good......I would leave out another brick pt2 except the solo part cus it doesn't really fit.....and putting goodbye cruel world at the end??? Outside the Wall is a great ending, and no the show must go on?? Well, i don't mean to pick on you buddy, i'm just very opinionated about my floyd

__________________
I can't think of anything to say...
Except
HeHeHe HoHoHo
I think it's marvelous
HeHeHe

DISC 2- is much better.

It's the Curate's egg, frankly

__________________
When Bucks Fizz’s tour bus crashed they all survived. When Metallica's bus crashed Cliff Burton died. Why?

Fixxy could actually have a point you know.

__________________
Only the very safe,
Can talk about wrong and right.
Of those that are forced to choose,
There's some who will choose to fight.

"Girlified"?

__________________
When Bucks Fizz’s tour bus crashed they all survived. When Metallica's bus crashed Cliff Burton died. Why?

Um, I don't know about the above comment, or where it fits in, but for me, it'd be mostly disc 1.

The Chancellor

__________________
"I'm not such a bad pilot myself"

Disc one, by far!

__________________
Come in here dear boy
have a cigar
you're gonna go far

-RW '75

i acturally prefer disc 2 to disc 1

hey you
is there anybody out there
nobody home
vera
bring the boys back home
comfortably numb




these songs above work incredibly well on disc 2 and are what i consider classic pink floyd, however both discs have surperb moments!!

Have you no ears?

ok "vera" and "bring the boys back home" arn't exactly classics but my point is that the first six songs from disc 2 work so well together!!