The Wall - Disc 1 or 2?

As personified by you?

No, I am goodness personified.

As in Goodness Gracious Me?

No, as in The Kumars At No.42.

Bring out the festive samosas!

Tough one... But...
Disc 2

I just find it better...if it's possible to compare these discs.

Almost impossible to say!!!

try to think they're an unique disc, THE WALL IS THE WALL, no divisions

__________________
"You lock the door and throw away the key
there's someone in my head but it's not me.

And if the cloud bursts, thunder in your ear
you shout and no one seems to hear
and if the band you're in starts playing different tunes
I'll see you on the dark side of the moon"

It's a toss-up, but I'm leaning towards disc 1.

Does anybody know the title of the movie playing in the background of "One of my turns" intro?
>".....Mrs Bancroft........."< (yadda, yadda, yadda......)

Disc 1 flows better and seems to have a more cohesive story line. Disc 2 has more ambitious songs and more orchestration.

And Disc 2 has the Trial, which is my favorite Floyd song. And it's also the end, and I'd rather hear the second half of a story than the first.

In the end, I'd take Disc 2. But can't I just listen to Disc 1 half the time and Disc 2 the other half?

:o :o :o :o

to each their one I suppose, or something like that....

__________________
"Don't you know there ain't no devil, it's just god when he's drunk." Tom Waits

It's f***in' brilliant. (Can you swear here? )

I'm a Roger Waters man. I think he's brilliant. The Trial is the perfect song to end the Wall. It's a perfect resolution to the story. The way the song is sung by all the different characters in a demented opera is like nothing else I've ever heard. I cherish uniqueness.

I'm trying to ascertain the title of the 'background' movie that's
playing behind the groupie's monolog during the intro of "One of
my turns".....!!
(Is it the 'Dambusters', or is that during a different part of The Wall?)

I dont think its about the songs.
To me.. Disc 2 is a million times better and i listen to it about 4 times a day minimum.

The way the songs flow together like a story just makes me want to understand every word in each song, every guitar pick, drum beat, or idea that ran into pink floyds head.





God

__________________
the primate's scream of consonance is a reflection of his own mind's dissonance

There is no life without death, no hapiness without tears, Im going to make you Cry.

Big Deal, Death Comes With Territory, see you in Disneyland

I would have to choose both. There is not a bad song either disk. Both disks have some of the most amazing music I have ever heard.

__________________
No Navigator To Find My Way Home