So who really wrote OotD, PowR TocH, Overdrive?

Most places say the whole band wrote these songs, but the sleves don't actually say. I think it's sort of a coincidence that the only tracks the other band members wrote on Piper are the instrumentals...

Actually, Roger wrote 'Take up thy stethoscope and walk'. That's not an instrumental. Plus, if you want to count the songs that were left off Piper that were put on Saucerful, there would have been others.

Just listen to this wise man...

cheers

I personally would think these songs were "written" by just jamming in the studio; therefore attributing it to the whole band would make perfect sense.

A lot of people say that Syd wrote "Overdrive".

Um... I didn't mention Stethoscope I don't think...

Yes, but you did say ONLY tracks on Piper written by other members.

....So one can only assume you were implying Stethoscope as well.

i must be getting slower but i can't for the life of me figure out what OotD is.

I was wondering the samething.

I figured it out after some long thought "one of these days"

ah no shit! its one of these days. i feel so retarded.

oh i guess you got it too. i left the page open so it was old when i posted.

I was thinking about songs from Piper and Saucerful

yeah me too

oh well we don't have to look stupid, we will just blame it on the topic starter for not telling us he meant meddle too!