question about saucerfull

i the album ASOS is an early PF album or after syd?

it is both early and half syd half without. there is only one song written by him and with his vocals. i have read that he played on remember a day and is doing something on set the controls.

really? he played in set the controls?
did he played in saucerfull (the song) i have no idea, i think not...
jugband blues is cetinly his - thats for sure
and another question?

who sing astronomy domine in TPatGoD?
and who sing astronomy domine on ummagumma live?

The Piper: Syd Barrett and Rick Wright
Ummagumma: Roger Waters

Syd is playing slide guitar on Remember a Day.
I'm not sure about his contribution, if any, on Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun.

I hear someone harmonizing with Roger on Ummagumma's "Astronomy Domine". Is this Rick?

i read in an interview with dave where he said that he thinks that syd did something on Set the Controls...

and on ummagumma i always thought it was dave and rick singing astronomy domine.

i was sure that waters was singing astronomy on ummagumma
i was also sure that water sang it in TPatGoD and the back up vouces were syd's...
a least i got one right.

Ummagumma version of Astronomy Domine is sung by Wright (lead vocals) with Gilmour (backing vocals). Studio version is Barrett & Wright.

I guess we don't know for sure who does it on Ummagumma... but it's definately Syd and Rick on Piper. Says so in the Echoes liner notes.

Syd does:
Slide guitar on Remember A Day
Guitar (acoustic and electric), lead vocals, and backup vox with the others on Jugband Blues
Guitar on Set the Controls (not the main riff, but those incidental feedback-y doodlings)

Also:
--from the indispensible Echoes FAQ.

Geez... add the 'possibility' of Syd being on Let There Be More Light and Saucerful of Secrets, and this might as well be Syd's album!!

Syd was in part of the album and the other part he left