Who REALLY Wrote 'Cirrus Minor'?

I've just noticed an anomaly of sorts, for the writing credits of "Cirrus Minor".
On the More LP, and on Relics, it's credited to all the members (Waters, Mason, Wright, Gilmour).
In the PF Encyclopedia, however, it is credited to Roger...
Who's wrong? Who's right?

Interesting. I've never heard of this anomaly. I don't know, we should ask the band I think. However, listening to the song it's hard to believe that (at least) Rick Wright hasn't writing credits.

Then again, what would be Nick's credit?

I do not believe the PF Encyclopedia was put out by PF itself. Personally, I'd be more inclined to trust official sources.

That's a good point, FloydWright.

Also, the Pink Floyd Fan Network (the page this forum spawns from) also includes the single Waters credit.

Perhaps someone could ask Mr. Dallagnol what source he used.

Also, do the credits differ on the CD releases at all?

My CD booklet (EMI early release, not remastered) says "Waters".

I know that this is totally off the subject at hand, but I noticed another anomaly.
The song "Ibiza Bar" reads "Ibizar Bar" on the label of my vinyl copy.
There's two anomalies going around now...
:shakehead:

And the difference is ??

Hang on , I've just spotted it

i'm sure the song was written by waters and the music by the others or just dave and rick.

Oh crap... I screwed up.
The More jacket says Waters. Relics says Waters. The band is only given credit on the damned label of More.
Sorry to get you guys all riled up.
Dump all the vitriol and ridicule you want on me... I am embarrassed!!!

Don't worry about it. From the looks of things, not many ppl got involved in this thread. We all make mistakes in reading things now and again. I do it all the time.

Red Bull gives you wings!