Animals or The Wall ?

no way The Wall is even the 2nd best Roger Waters written work:

(1) ANIMALS
(2) DARK SIDE OF THE MOON
(3) WISH YOU WERE HERE
(4) AMUSED TO DEATH
(5) PRO'S AND CONS OF HITCH HIKING
(6) THE WALL

Oh my.

Indeed.

the wall is number one!

put Pro's and Cons in there as a joke to draw out that one member who is obbsessed with The Wall...at least i didn't include RADIO K.A.O.S...

oh my.

Animals is my FAVORITE Floyd album over all the others
Just a masterpiece

Animals is better in my opinon because its music is really just played to a higher level than the wall. Althogh the wall has more memrable songs and made me obsessed with Floyd. Animals is just better for a unexplainable reason and if it wernt for The animals tour(in the flesh) The Wall probly wouldnt have been made into what it is today

hardest question ever! both of them are awesome and also my favorites
but actually i love every tracks in animals, they have brilliant lyrics and of course the music... it goes deep deep inside of your soul and mind
also like the wall, couz songs like comfortably numb, hey you, run like hell, mother and more

The Wall. Animals is done well - I don't dislike it - but it is not the type of music that appeals to me as much. I do listen to it on a regular basis though.

animal a great album indeed, but the wall got me. i find the wall better!!

Well....The Wall
I like following an epic musical AND lyrical narrative. Dark Side... had the musical narrative, so did WYWH. The only thing that hangs Animals together as a complete piece is Pigs On The Wing 1&2. Otherwise, it's just 3 long musically unrelated songs. (Although Dogs is my favorite song ever!)

So the wall is like a movie for your ears with a logical musical progression. It has to have the "boring" bits like any movie otherwise the whole movie is boring, going full out at one pace. The Wall is beautifully paced and a truly satisfying listen. If every song was a classic, it would be annoying almost as one tries to follow the lyrical narrative, trying to get the meaning while there are no dynamics at all!

An action movie has to have the quiet "I love You" bits in order for the action bits to have the most impact. The Wall needs the "Vera"s and "Don't Leave Me Now"s to make the action bits like Comfortably Numb and Hey You to stand out and have the desired impact.

So that is my essay on why I like The Wall Best!

I win.

The Wall is too long and has too many fillers. Though it does have a few good songs. However Animals is a different story. All the songs are great and fit like a puzzle. The guitars, bass, keys, drums, vocals and lyrics all blend well together and blow me away. I also enjoy the raw production which is evident in Animals. Along with Wish You Were Here, it's my favorite Pink Floyd album.