"David Gilmour in Concert" set to air on VH1 Classic

I am new to this forum and I sincerely hope that there is some one still reading matters related to David Gilmour in Concert. I started many many years ago thinking that Gilmour was the back bone of the Floyd. But many years of study about the band (a Ph.D) involving them has made me veer to the conclusion that the greatest contribution towards the making of Pink Floyd did come from Waters. Please listen to the solo work of both the artists and you will see that it is waters who is much closer to the Pink Floyd genre. Gilmour in concert is missing something though I cannot really pin point what exactly the problem is.
Sadsack

Where on earth did you get a Ph.D in Pink Floyd?

I'd like to get one of them, maybe ill get a scholarship and not pay!

I could probably teach classes.

This is an old thread but I am new to the forum so I hope I will get indulged a little. I saw this DVD of David Gilmour in Concert. Its available only recently in my country and I would definitely say it is not what I expected. I am a Water's fan but I will not bring him into the equation since this has nothing do with him. But I have always admired Gilmour's sense of music and playing ability and I found that this concert was dissappointing. The new song Smile is quite not upto scratch.
Sadsack

At least Dave's sense of humour was still on display.