Your full PF report card for official releases

No matter if this is a DDT, I just saw NNJ stating PF career has more downs than ups and he's probably not the only one in here who thinks this way. So I'd like to have a complete view of your opinions about PF studio and live official releases.

Let's use a rating from 3 to 10 (0, 1 and 2 are useless) working this way:

3: Pure crap, this just has nothing to do with music, only business. A shame.
4: Complete lack of inspiration, all in all a useless album.
5: There's nothing special here, it's just for hardcore fans.
6: Average; has its good moments but the typical PF greatness is somewhere else
7: Rather good, I think everyone interested in rock music should give it a listen, sooner or later.
8: Probably I think this way just cos I'm a big PF fan, but this is effing beautiful! Everyone slightly interested in rock music must have this!
9: Definitely a masterpiece, not only for PF fans. Essential in every collection.
10: The best album I've ever heard in my life. I severely doubt I'll ever listen something better than this. A milestone in music history, and if you don't agree you're either deaf or dumb (here intended as "idiot"), or both.

Half points are allowed, and if you want to add some comments it's even better.

Btw, here's mine:

The Piper - 9
ASoS - 8
More - 6
Ummagumma - 6,5 (studio - 5 ; live - 8)
AHM - 7
Meddle - 7
OBC - 6
DSOTM - 7
WYWH - 7
Animals - 8,5
The Wall - 8
ITAOT - ? (never heard)
TFC - 6,5
AMLOR - 5,5
DSOT - 5
TDB - 6
Pulse - 5,5

others:

Relics - 8
Radio KAOS - 6,5
ATD - 7,5

OBC, 8
Meddle, 7
DSOTM, 7
WYWH, 8
Animals, 9
The Wall, 8
TFC, 7
AMLOR, 6
TDB, 6
...These are the only one's i've heard, I don't have the whole discography yet.

i give all of there albums 10 , no questions asked.

Well,
Ummaguma gets a 6
OBC, Meddle, DSOTM, TDB all get 7's
WYWH and Animals get 8.5's
AMLOR gets a 5, SORRY GUYS!
Pro's and Cons and Amused To Death both get a 7.5

Off topic but, Tales from Topographic Oceans Relayer and Close To The Edge all get 10++++++++++++++

The EEOC would like the DP to see the MOC about the MRT.

Piper - 6.5
Saucerful - 5
Ummagumma - (live) 6; (studio) 5
More - 7
AHM - 7
Obscured By Clouds - (haven't heard)
Meddle - 8
DSOTM - 10
WYWH - 9
Animals - 8
The Wall - 9.5
TFC - 8
AMLOR - 6
TDB - (haven't heard)
ITAOT? - 8

Pros and Cons?... - 5

The Piper - 5
ASoS - 6
More - 5
Ummagumma - (studio - 3 ; live - 8)
AHM - 5
Meddle - 8 (and let's face it, that's cause of Echoes, otherwise it'd get a 4)
OBC - 8
DSOTM - 10
WYWH - 8
Animals - 10
The Wall - 7
ITAOT - 8
TFC - 7
AMLOR - 5
DSOT - 5
TDB - 3
Pulse - 3

others:

Relics - 8
Pro's and Cons - 3
Radio KAOS - 3
ATD - 7

Someplaces might be a little Harsh, but that could be just because I can't get throught the rough parts to get to the good parts

Piper - 6
ASoS - 7
More - 6
Ummagumma - 5 (s - 3, l - 8)
AHM - 7
Relics - 6
Meddle - 8
OBC - 7
DSotM - 10
WYWH - 9
Animals - 8
The Wall - 8
ACoGDS - 3
TFC - 6
AMLoR - 6
DSoT - 4
TDB - 7
Pulse - 6
ITAOT - 8
Echoes - 3

Others:

Music From The Body - 4
Pros & Cons - 3
Radio KAOS - 4
The Wall Live in Berlin - 3
ATD - 7
ITF - 6
Flickering Flame - 5
DG - 6
AF - 6
BC - 7

This is hard to do because I like all the albums a lot. But I know I don't like them all the same.

Piper's at the Gates of Dawn - 9
A Saucerful of Secrets - 8
More - 7
Ummagumma - 9
Atom Heart Mother - 10
Meddle - 9
Obscured By Clouds - 8
Dark Side of the Moon - 10
Wish You Were Here - 10
Animals - 9
The Wall - 8
The Final Cut - 8
A Momentary Lapse of Reason - 7
The Division Bell - 10

Other Stuff

1967 The 3 First Singles - 8
Relics - 9
Works - 9
A Collection of Great Dance Songs - 9
A Saucerful of Outtakes - 8
More Relics - 9
The Madcap Laughs - 8
Barrett - 6
Opal - 6
The Pros and Cons of Hitchhiking - 5
Amused to Death - 7
Wet Dream - 9
Broken China - 9
David Gilmour - 8
Profiles - 5

There that is all the Pink Floyd stuff I have

Ok here's mine, anyway I could probably post another one with different ratings tomorrow so... it's just a game.

Piper - 7
ASoS - 7.5
More - 6.5
Ummagumma - 5/7
AHM - 7
Meddle - 8
OBC - 6.5
DSotM - 10
WYWH - 10
Animals - 8.5
The Wall - 7
TFC - 5
AMLoR - 6.5
DSoT - 6.5
TDB - 8.5
Pulse - 8
ITAOT - 8

No ratings for anthologies, sorry.
And as for solo albums I just cannot give ratings in comparison to the band efforts. I mean, what I consider a 7 for a solo Floyd would probably be a 6 for the band. With this in mind, here we go:

David Gilmour - 7
About Face - 4
Madcap Laughs - 6.5
Barrett - 6.5
Wet Dream - 7
Broken China - 8
Identity - 4.5
Pros & Cons - 4.5
Radio Kaos - 4
The Wall Live In Berlin - 3
Amused To Death - 7.5
In The Flesh - 5
David Gilmour In Concert - 8

Fictitious Sports and Profiles: never heard entirely, I guess I'm lucky

interesting idea . . .

Piper at the Gates of Dawn -- 9.0
A Saucerful of Secrets -- 8.0
More -- 7.5
Ummagumma -- 5-studio, 8.0 live
Atom Heart Mother -- 7.0
Meddle -- 7.5
Obscured by Clouds -- 5.5
Dark Side of the Moon -- 10.0
Wish You Were Here -- 10.0
Animals -- 10.0
Wall -- 9.0
The Final Cut -- 7.0
A Momentary Lapse of Reason -- 8.0
The Division Bell -- 6.5
Pulse -- 8.5
In the Flesh -- 8.5
The Wall Live -- 9.5
Amused to Death -- 9.0

I was going to get The Pro's and Con's before I read these reviews. Is it really that bad?

It's worse! Bleh!

this is all the stuff i own

now of course next to many other bands all these albums are a 10 but in comparison to other pink floyd stuff:

piper at the gates of dawn 7
a saucerful of secrets 7.5
atom heart mother 9
ummagumma 6.5
relics 8
obscured by clouds 9
meddle 9
animals 8.5
the wall 8.5
momentary lapse of reason 8
the division bell 8.5
pulse 10
dark side of the moon 10
wish you were here 10
is there anybody out there 9
echoes 8
about face 7
wouldn't you miss me ? 9

i also have these albums on my computer:
final cut 2
More 7.5

and believe it or not i actually once owned
amused to death 0
-but i gave it away for free to someone who actually likes it so i guess thats good.

sadly i have yet to hear
works or dsot

Get it! It's an excellent CD!!