OBC or Meddle????

In my opinion Meddle wins, but I'm curious to see what you all think.

Meddle , cause it is the most Pink Floyd team work project , where all 4 members are still friends , still joking around .
and i dont have OBC .

Too close to call. Maybe Meddle though, just.
Maybe not.

echoes is spectacular but its not the whole album. OBC is all brilliant.

VV

OBC, easily.

Echoes is a great song, but OBC is a great album.

Echoes is amazing, just that takes the whole OBC album, though thier both GREAT albums! *production is terrible in OBC*

Meddle pisses all over OBC. One of these Days, Fearless, San tropez and Echoes are all fantastic. OBC is a decent album (I love 'Free Four'), despite being let down by the terrible last track, but no way is it better than Meddle.

IMO.

I really love OBC but Meddle just plays in another league. One Of These Days and Echoes are two all-time classics.

I think meddle wins out because it is better sonically. OBC however sounds good because it ws recorded in france in two weeks and the band didn't think it would be listened to very much.

"There is no pain you are receding"
[I]

Obviously Meddle, that is not a perfect album or a masterpiece but certainly better than an unpretentious soundtrack.

i hated to choose. but because of 'pillow of winds' and 'fearless' i had to choose Meddle. but damn what a decision. looking at all that OBC has to offer:

burning bridges
wots...uh the deal
mudmen
childhoods end
stay

: i wish i could have voted twice.

arg. why do you torture me so?!!?!