Quote:
Originally posted by downhill
I disagee on your idea of what Guthrie ment when he was comparing DVD-A to SACD sonic wise......Again, I doubt that anyone could tell the difference betwen the two formats taken into account both of them were done right.... |
He wasn't comparing DVD-A and SACD, he was comparing AC-3 and DTS to DSD. MLP and DSD are nearly identical, I agree. But Guthrie's point is that nobody who buys DVD-As and plays them on regular DVD players is going to hear the MLP, they are going to hear the DTS or AC-3 (because it's a regular DVD player and not fully MLP compatible), and those are without doubt quite inferior to MLP and certainly inferior to DSD.
Quote:
| as to clipping..an exageration maybe on the whole album..but done just like a lot of new cd's and remixes....too much compression....check it out for yourself if you have something to look at a wav file.....Rip a bunch of the tracks and look at them with something like Cooledit...... |
It's a little compressed, maybe 1db. But there's absolutely no clipping. A slight amount of compression is a side-effect of the DSD process, but I'm more than willing to live with it because the resulting sound is so smooth and warm.
05-09-2003, 01:03 PM
Similar Threads for DSOTM DVD Audio? 
