Top 5 Pink Floyd Albums

How can you hate the Wall so much and then love it?! o_O

New List:

1. Wish
2. Meddle
3. Obscured
4. Atom
5. Umma

Well if you're not listening to the MFSL CD then the sound of the vinyl is bound to be a revelation.

Spot on. Plus I listened to it in-depth, plus I watched the movie a few times.

The top 2 will always be my favourites; the other three change constantly;

1-DSOTM
2-Animals

3-Meddle
4-Saucerful
5-More

My top albums are(least love to greatest):

5. The Division bell
4. Meddle
3. Piper at the gates of dawn
2. Dark side of the moon
1. Is there anybody out there? The Wall live 1980-1981

1. DSOTM- Obvious reasons here

2. Atom Heart Mother- Way Way underrated album.

3. Wish You Were Here- Last great Floyd album before Waters became the dictator

4. Meddle- Way cool stuff here.

5. Ummagumma- The live cd is incredible and the studio stuff is very interesting

Personaly I hated the album 1st time I heard it but it's since grown on me. It's by no way their best work but it is an good album and well worth the work of getting into it.

On that note having already posted my top 5 Floyd albums here are my Top 5 that have grown on me or i have discovered having let them get lost in my collection.

1) Atom Heart Mother - this is a great album whislt not as cohesive as other albums it constantly throws up new ideas and the use of 'real' objects as sound effects, an intresting listen.

2) Ummagumma - And not just the live bit though that is great, but I think the individual members sections are also great with Gilmour's TNW pt 2 & 3 and SSOSFAGIACWAP shining tracks.

3) The Division Bell - Gilmour's guitar is fantastic and whilst not the concept album that Right hoped it to be still dose raise some thoughtful points.

4) Animals - I absolutly hated this album on CD it sounds like a half hearted filler between WYWH and TW but now I have it on LP I can hear it for the album it truly is which is a bloody good one.

5) A Momentary Lapse Of Reason - Overall not the best of albums however the highpoints are very good and it certaintly grows the more time you give to it.

DSOM
WYWH
TW
SFOS
AHM

Right Now:

The Wall
AMLOR
Dark Side of the Moon
Meddle
Wish you were Here

In no particular order, 'DSOTM', 'WYWH', um, 'M', 'OBC' & ITABOT:TWL

1. Piper at the gates of Dawn - brilliant debute

2. Dark Side of The Moon

3. Wish You Were Here

4. The Wall

5. Ummagumma ( live )

ANIMALS

MORE

PATGOD

AHM

WALL

let me see...

1. dark side of the moon- just .....because
2. the wall live- perhaps the greatest thing ive ever heard
3. division bell- amazing music and very close to my heart personally
4. animals- good stuff
5. cant choose between wish you were here and the final cut- both accomplish what they were meant to be and more

5. Meddle- Echoes duh.
4. Saucerful of Secrets- All 5 of Floyd
3. Dark Side of the Moon- Perfection,but for some reason i like the next two more
2. Piper at the Gates of Dawn-greatest psychedelic rock album ever.
1. Wish You Were Here- Shine on Syd

1. Wish You Were Here
2. Wish You Were Here
3. Wish You Were Here
4. Wish You Were Here
5. Wish You Were Here

The other albums were good, too.