The REAL Which Mother thread

[WatersWannabe]

what parts does dave sing on in Mother?

o and the ITAOT version is great how he changes the "mother am i really dying?" line the new fits in the story beter

[Botley]

Dave sings the part of the Mother. Roger sings Pink's lyrics.

Little known fact: Roger changed that lyric every night just to see if Dave was paying attention. Other examples include:

Is it just a waste of time?
Mother am I really dying?
Mother can you spare a dime?
This tequila needs a lime.
If you can hear this whisper, you're dying.
Would you be my Valentine?
I think I forgot the line.

[Bowen]

i think the album version is great

even though ITAOT is good too

[Les_Paul]

I voted for the ITAOT version because it seem to have more energy, and when Dave kind of changes the way he sings some of the lyrics (makes them more. . .good) but I have one problem. Why make the solo longer, the more I think about it I'd rather them have kept the studio solo.

[PinksWall]

I like the movie version best. The slow rhythm is a nice change to the song.

[Les_Paul]

Originally posted by PinksWall
I like the movie version best. The slow rhythm is a nice change to the song.

The movie version fits perfectly into the movie, but if that was what they did live I'd be bored out of my mind.

[PinksWall]

Yes I would too.

[Hove]

I miss Dave's guitar on In The Flesh, but it is the best version by far for one reason:

Katie Kissoon!!!