DSOT or Pulse?

i "hate" both albums but i voted for pulse

__________________
I've been mad for fuc*ing years...


If I were a good man, I'd talk to you more often than I do

Pulse, only because i fell in love with the comfortably Numb Version on this album

__________________
"Together we stand , Divided we fall"

The PULSE Comfortably Numb solo is pretty hardcore, but it irks me that Roger doesn't sing the parts of the doctor. I don't really like the other guys' voice. David sings his parts tremendously, and plays a badass extended solo, but without Roger I can't quite see it being better than the other versions.

__________________
Breathe

Yeah, the verses sound pretty bad with that bloated harmony.

__________________
"...Did we do anything after this?"

"I've a feeling we did..."

DSoT just because I happen to like the songs on the Momentary Lapse of Reason dics with DSoT than I lilked the Division Bell stuff on Pulse, although I find the other two cd's of each to be almost equally as good.

I'm really un descided. I like DSOT because it has brilliant songs like Learning To Fly; Sorrow; On The Turning Away. It had One Of These Days (Which the pulse discs did not) and a better version of 'Money' and 'Comfortably Numb'.

PULSE had extremely good lighting effects, but then again so did DSOT just not as good.

im probably 49% towards PULSE
51% towards DSOT

I'd choose DSoT because of the song list. Though I'd leave out ABitW2 cos it's so out of context on both cds!!!

__________________
... and the pink queen sat and smiled at the cat who smiled back...

You must have a really good cd player cos the lighting effects just don't come over that well on mine.

I love Pulse, so that gets my vote everyday of the week and twice on a Sunday, I can't believe that anyone could dislike the solo on CN, to me it's an utterly inspiring piece of guitar work - the big man at his finest. But, each to their own I suppose.

Pulse also has, IMO, the best version of SOYCD recorded. It was my introduction to the Floyd, so it has a sentimental value to me...

__________________
I'm Garth Marenghi - author, dream-weaver, visionary. Plus actor. You are about to enter the world of my imagination. This is my Darkplace.

You're also overlooking the fact that DSOT is a bit crap! Also I can't listen to it without picturing all those mullet hairdos!!

I kinda like DSoT, too though. It's growing on me.

__________________
I'm Garth Marenghi - author, dream-weaver, visionary. Plus actor. You are about to enter the world of my imagination. This is my Darkplace.

A bit like your mullet? Don't try to deny it!

I don't have a mullet, I can assure you of that. The fact that have eyes and can see means that it is impossible for me to seriously grow a mullet. If I did, I'd go blind (and not for the reasons you're thinking, you dirty-minded people).

__________________
I'm Garth Marenghi - author, dream-weaver, visionary. Plus actor. You are about to enter the world of my imagination. This is my Darkplace.

It's a true story.

__________________
"Don't you know there ain't no devil, it's just god when he's drunk." Tom Waits