Wish You were here !Vs. Wish You were here!

I admit Roger can not sing WYWH it was not horrible but it was not great.

I like Dave's versions but I too think the original is the best.

I THINK THE ORIGINAL STUDIO VERSION.

I prefer Dave's version.

The original version is simply the best. I did not like the In The Flesh version.

i like both of them very much

"RAPE?Well DAVE DID THE SAME TO ABITW-2 on PULSE!!" AND wot about "any color u like ?' to copy live performance of a live gig ,huh ,anyway,I disagree that roger cant sing!!He may not be in A list but his "FINAL CUT ,WALL & SOLOS are rendered with perfect vocal emotion;i.e. rendering each song in its context with the vocals"

Well in the end we are all just same lost souls ,swimmin in the same fish bowl ..........fears .And if u wish to see him perform WYWH live IN INDIA's pix ,see attachment.

I thought gilmour done a great job a great job of another brick....part on pulse, and his performance in any colour you like was amazing, sounded great.

Waters really doesnt sing wywh too well though, not terrible, but in comparison with gilmour

i did voted for the original one, though i liked the women vocals in ITF version.

I think 'Pulse' is the best cut of WYWH.

Also I wouldn't say Dave 'raped' ABITW2 - he sang the original verison now didn't he? On DSOT he gave a poor performance but on PULSE I thought he did quite well.

I find that live music is generally better than the studio cut, I think the end chorus that Roger put at the end of Shine On was a bit superfluous, but the rest of the song is good, and Dave is good at just standing on the stage in complete darknesss and unleashing the guitar on us.

orig.

the odds get even .. you name the gamethe odds get even..the stakes are the samethe odds get even...You Bet Your Life!!Why dont we even the odds and get into LIFE? The song remains the same ;while my guitar gently weeps....