The Wall-Best Album from the Waters Domination era

I think that The wall is the best Waters domination era pink floyd album, and I'm not saying that because it was the most successfull commercially(Heaven sake NO), But because of the Beautifull and powerfull lyrics,amazing music, and the energy that flows from this album. Plus It's not an entirely Roger's work but almost, cause David Gilmour wrote "Comfortably Numb" & "Run Like Hell" Plus he played the hell out of an amzing Guitar(altough not like in Echoes in Pompeii or Shine on you Crazy Diamond on WYWH).

Best commercially? Probably.
Best Musicaly? Definitely! :smile:
(Those remarks relate to the waters era. My favourite PF Album is Wish you were here and my Favorite era is 1968-1975)

What do you fokes think? do you agree?
maybe not?

Dark Side was the best commercially, it is #4 on the all time best sellers list. At least according to Billboard. And I think you know my thoughts on the album being the best musically.

I ment Best commercialy and best Musically
In the waters Domination era, You silly Dude! :smile:

I know that DSOTM Was the all time best commarcially and I think that WISH YOU WERE HERE is their best musicially.
If you have read all of my message you would have known that.

Cheers...

So, let me get this straight before piling in with my tuppence worth. In your opinion:

DSOTM was the best PF album commercially. Okay.
WYWH was the best PF album musically. Check.

So, how does The Wall manage to be the best (overall?) Waters era PF album? I'm confused.

All clear-cut responses, and not-so-clear-cut as well, greatly appreciated. :smile:

Cheers,
Byron

"His luminous grin put her in a spin."

Pay attantion:

Waters era 1968-1983
Waters DOMINATION era 1977-1983

Ya See?

So best album for waters era is WYWH
and best album for waters DOMINATION era is
The Wall.

I think you just confused the hell out of all of us! :smile:

No actually i understand.

And i basically agree!

Archer I totally do not understand what you are saying. Charade You Are, are you as confused as I?

I see...well then no. It's not.

Well, that's as clear as mud.

In any case, this is a flawed premise on which to continue a forum: "Which is the best PF album?"

One may as well ask what's the world's best colour? Different albums will appeal to different people differently.

See my previous "Opinions are like arseholes..." comment for clarity.

Cheers,
Byron

"I feel one of my turns coming on."

_________________
Don't mess with the eagles until you learn how to fly!

It is the best in this era! Definitely!
But 'Animals' comes close to it.
Pesonaly I don't like 'The Final Cut' not that much.
Yeah, I think 'The Wall' is the best in in this era

I won't get into why I don't believe The Wall is a good album. But I will second Byron's notion that opinions are like assholes.

I think I'll have 2 agree, I like The Wall better than Animals and 2 be honest I don't really know The Final Cut all that well.

Btw, I didn't know Gilmour wrote "Comfortably Numb", wow.. it's one of my favorite songs on this album! Cool.

But still, Wish You Were Here is my alltimes favorite.

Gilmour didn't write ALL of Comfy Numb, silly, just the music, Waters gets all the credit for the lyrics.

Thanks NNJohn.

Floyd on!
Byron

BTW, "Works" is THE best PF album EVER!

"Maisie, lay in hole..."