Waters Rejoining Floyd....a good or bad thing????

[quote]Originally posted by FloydWright
[b]Has Mr. Waters grown more forgiving? Only on the surface, I think--maybe he doesn't say "F--- Pink Floyd" as much as he used to. But look how he skewered Mr. Wright in the 1999 Mojo article.

I haven't seen this article, what exactly did Roger say about Rick?

Roger Waters 'rejoins' Pink Floyd ? Assuming that the bonds of respect and comradeship could be, errr, restored, and that some kind of creative commonground could be, ummm, established (and that various testicles may be removed from a certain pig) ... sure, why not.
Thing is though, it better be bloody good ...

__________________
Thoughts meander like a restless wind inside a letterbox ...

It's nice to dream but anyone with an ounce of common sense knows it's never going to happen.

Even though Nick Mason joined Roger on stage last year, I don't believe the foursome can work together again. Rick and Dave never got along with Roger, and I don't think these feelings have not endured to this day. And, not to annoy Wright fans, but the main reason he got the boot was that, besides his almost null contribution to The Wall album (Most of the keyboard work was done by Peter Wood and Bob Ezrin, though they're not credited) his liking for coke. I love Rick's playing style, but he was creatively drained from the time Animals came about.

I do not want them to work together again - would be like a betray to those of us who believe in Roger's integrity. The band's members are okay on their own and all we need to do is keep playing the band's cds until the cows come home. I really can't imagine them going on tour together. Neither Roger or Dave want the whole lighting circus ever again, let alone Nick or Rick.

It would be great for those of us who are not old enough to have seen the "real" Pink Floyd live.

I would wager money that they will do a reunion concert some day, possibly even a tour. But they won't make another record together.

From everything I know about this, it is unlikely you will see anymore PF new projects, with or w/o R. Waters.

Never going to happen.What if's aren't even an option.It will never happen.

Never say never.

__________________
Moving On.....

If Floyd got back together with Roger, it wouldn't be the same songwriting wise.
-Like the Sonny and Cher show. When they got back together the second time (and they weren't married) the chemisty wasn't the same. (I don't like Sonny and Cher, but I watch a lot of VH1 Behind the Music)

__________________
...and if you're reading this, I'll see you on the Dark Side of the Moon.

I've never seen Pink Floyd compared to the Sonny and Cher Show before!

You obviously haven't been to any of the many 'Let's compare Pink Floyd to the Sonny and Cher Show' forums that are all the rage on the Internet nowadays.

__________________
is snuggly

I've lead such a sheltered life.

roger should take out his secret weapon , which is living in cambridge , somewhere , just give the man a guitar and lock h'm for 48 hours , and we don't need freakin gilmour , anymore !!

Bollocks.