A momentary lapse of reason or the DB

Personally I didn't enjoy AMLoR very much. That's not to say it doesn't have a few good tunes here and there...but TDB is definatly superior. Just very good in general...great sound, great performances (and yes...I find that even though the lyrics are nowhere up to par with RW's work, it is good).

Go with TDB first...but AMLoR should be gotten later. Much later.

MUCH much later

I like Division Bell better.

They both suck, not true Floyd album. But if I have to choose betwn them I'll choose TDB.

They both are pretty good, but I like Division Bell better, its more complete, I can listen to it all the way through. AMLOR has the better lyrics though and that classic 80's feel.

whichever one's cheaper

'Farthest Alaska of my record collection'

From top to bottom, I'd go with The Division Bell. Although I don't think any of the songs on the Division Bell are as good as On The Turning Away

the turning away is a very good song, i am not a huge fan of 'amlor!' dogs of war just did't sound floydesque! it was okay once it got into it, but gilmore doesn't seem to have the same progressive writing talents as waters!

The Division Bell is best. Wearing The Inside Out is fantastic.

AMLOR is very good, but not better than TDB.

Neither are really spectacular, but they're both worth at least listening to if you're a fan, IMO.

I'll pick AMLOR. For some reason, all the tracks on TDB except the last two bore the bejeezus out of me.

I'm with you. "Much much later" made me smile too