Hey you

I was wondering who sings most of PF songs.... waters or gilmour? I read that it was waters but wasnt too sure... and which is it that sings the song Hey you? thank you for your help..sorry if this topic is too newbieish for you.. ha.

Welcome, and worry not about "newbieish quaestions"... how else you gonna learn?


Waters sings Hey You...

I'd say the vocal responsibilities were about 50/50 actually..

gilmour signs hey you up until 'open your heart i'm coming home' and then roger signs until the end.

ok thanks guys!

Tru'nuff.....

well i know my pink stuff!!

Like a **** ***, do we?


Mod edit, Inappropriate content, & language

This member excluded from the site for 1 week

Whoa! big fella... steppin' over the line there..

Welcome to the site! As you've seen already, it's a tremendous resource for increasing your Floydian knowledge. Just for future reference: On the main page of this site, there are links to info about albums, including lyrics and who sung what. Quite handy, if I may say so...

Oh yeah, and if you haven't been warned, people here are very sensitive to DDTs (Dreaded Duplicate Threads). It's easily avoided if you just do a search for whatever it is you are considering posting about.

I think members should get at least an email stating that they have been banned.

yeah, waters/gilmour sing 50%, and wright sings some too....i love when roger sings...wow. and on hey you, gilmour sings the first bit, and then waters sings the other bits...very nicely...

I always find Roger's voice in the final verse to be right on the limit, whereas when you hear Richard Wright singing that part on Pulse it sounds effortless (or was it Guy Pratt? Sounds like Wright to me).

Whichever, it was a much stronger voice - Roger sounds weak on Hey You.

Can anyone point me in the direction of a list of who played and sang which bits on every Floyd song? I'm sure fragments of such things exist and there may be a few bits scattered around this forum but does anyone know or have a definitive list?

Ta.

The answer is Jon Carin. See http://www.pinkfloydfan.net/showthre...ighlight=carin

Hey I was just wondering on Echoes their greatest hits album, who sang more songs?

Dave did. But then, he compiled it after all!

Dave - 7
Roger - 6
Syd - 4
Roger and Dave - 3
Dave and Richard - 2
Syd and Richard - 1
Nick - 1
Clare Torry - 1