DVD commentary for The Wall

Whenever I put on the commentary for The Wall, I only hear Gerald Scarfe talking, no Roger Waters. Has anyone else experienced this before, and if so what did you do? Thank you for your help.

Never tried it

that's really strange, you should hear him explaining most of the scenes and songs. i hear it with my copy

I'm assuming that you have two audio cables yet one socket in your tv to plug in? That was my problem. If I had one in I'd hear, out of both speakers, what should be coming out of one of them.

I recently got a Y-shaped jack to plug both of them in and now I can hear both of them way better. It's a big improvement on my sound.

Now I'm going to go through my 70-something DVDs, listen to all of my commentaries and concert films

Turn on the Roger commentary. Then he'll give his opinions freely

As if he needs an option on the DVD. He'll give it to us whether we like it or not.

Yes

Good ol' rog.

whenever i listen to the commentary....i only hear Roger talking..

i just bought it and havent listened to the commentary yet.

that my Roger he says whatever he feels when he wants to

If you only hear one person and not the other, then either you're missing an audio cable (as Poggle Zig says), or the balance on your TV is turned all the way to the left or to the right. Roger is in the left speaker and Gerald's on the right.