Unfortunate

Methinks it's time to create a community titled "All Floyd Is Good".
I know FloydWaters will join me there. Who else ?
I'm ALMOST serious, folks. You all know how much I adore Dave but the more I live the more I understand that the answer to the question "which one's Pink" are four names (prolly even five names)...not just one.
Innit ???

man this argument is getting old... will you just move on?!!

ALL FLOYD IS GOOD!!!!!

what would you rather listen to?? till this day I prefer AMLOR and TDB (which seem to get bashed alot) over any other non-floyd material... don't you??

hey man ill join you in that new forum thingee, i mean i thik roger is a fag sometiems cos of how he tried to take credit for lots of things, but i still think he made great music. but of course i love them all, expecially wright and mason, they remind me of the LEd Zepplin Movie, the song remains the same, you see John Paul Jones and John Bonham sortof talking to each other about stuff in the background while Page and Plant prance around on stage getting all the credit, not saying i dont like them either, if u can figure out who im liking everyone too then you win a prize, but anyway wat im trying to say is ill join that thing, and to sum up lots i love all pink floyd, no one can convince me momentary and divison bell suck, got it?

thanx guys, nice to hear some positive words here !!!
LOL

I would join you there...I'm kind of having some trouble right now on another message board. Seems one is not allowed to enjoy and respect Mr. Waters' work if you also enjoy and respect the work of the other Floydians. ESPECIALLY if you are a fan of Mr. Wright! And God help you if they figure out your personality might be a bit similar to his!

_________________
"But now the day has broken, can see in better ways,
A path leading to the light, a hope that never fades.
All power to the brave."

--"Along the Shoreline" by Richard Wright

Comfortably Numb, there's a whole lot of music that I would rather listen to than Momentary Lapse Of Reason and Division Bell.

I really don't think all this arguing is necessary. RW is good, no doubt about that, but who wants to listen to his complaining all the time? It does wear a bit thin, so I'm not surprised that Dave and Nick couldn't stand him later.

AMLOR and TDB are good in their own ways so I don't see why they are constantly bashed. Just because they don't sound 'Floyd' enough doesn't mean that they aren't Floyd.

I think I agree:

ALL FLOYD IS GOOD

even if not to the standards set by their earlier music.

ahhh, forget pink floyd all together. 'the madcap laughs' is better than the whole lot.

yeah it is so good.

Eugeneaxe, don't hate people for liking a certain Floyd memeber then other. It happens in every band. For me it's Dave simply because he was my inspiration to play guitar.

I have my favorite too. I was just saying don't hate the other members, like some people do.

Yeah that's cool mate. Just don't get annoyed or let others do it to you. There are people that love to do that.

Pros and Cons sucked, Division Bell sucked.

In The Flesh hands down beats PULSE.


AMLOR is marginally better than Radio KAOS.

So everyone shut up already, nobody, not even a member (or ex-member) of Floyd is perfect.