Worst song On Saucerful?

I really love the song See-saw (about Syd?) and deteste Corporal clegg!

Yet people seem to adore CC and despise See-saw...even Rick!

so what is the worst for you?

no point going best cos Remember a day and Set the controls will swamp it.

Corporal Clegg is one of the only songs in the entire Floyd catalog that I skip over (the only other ones I skip past are all on "More"- but that's another topic).

you don't like Cymbaline fella?

I voted for the title track, it's shite.

Cymbaline is fine. I didn't say I disliked the entire "More" album, but I think it has a few "draggers". Some I really like. Ibiza Bar rocks. Up the Khyber sounds like it should be part of the title track on "Saucer". Some (Crying Song, More Blues) I skip over.

I love Corporal Clegg. It's one of Floyd's more rocking songs.

I said "rocking", not best!!

The studio version of the title track is crappy. See-Saw is not bad, just dull, dull, dull. Good organ/keyboard bit.

ASOS is a thoroughly average album which isn't one of my favourites. I bemoan its loss, however (I left it on the train) because it means I have to buy it again at some point.

This is my favorite album. I love all of the songs, especially Corporal Clegg. I think the worst song would be the title track.

I'm was to say DDT but the old one got deleted. See Saw, by a significant margin.

from favourite to least:

Remember A Day
Jugband
ASOS
Set The Controls
LTBML
See Saw
Clegg


my only skipper is Clegg.

I like Corporal Clegg!

The worst is See-Saw.

I never skip any tracks in Floyd albums!

Oops. I meant to vote for See-Saw..not Remember a Day. Kinda tough to tell between some Wright songs when they pretty much sound the same.

How can you even ask that question?

Wihtout a doubt the song ASOS from the album is the very worst. The rest of the album is good but this song is 12 minutes of rambling incoherent sounds.

I voted for See saw... before I saw ASOS on Pompeii (bought it last week!) I thought that ASOS was the worst. I really like this album though... all of it. CC's guitar is interesting... and kind of fun. ASOS has Gilmour's vocal... Remember a day is GREAT... I love it. LTBML is my favorite, and Set the Controls was the first song I learned to play on guitar... the tab version from this website at least. See Saw... is boring... but I like it when the mood strikes.