What is Less Floyd-like, TFC or TDB?

PS I just got Final Cut and Division Bell this past Friday. Division Bell is more like Floyd than anything from Dark Side on. Final Cut was just Roger whining about God knows what again. It's Gilmour and Wright's voices versus Roger's that makes the difference.

Less Floyd like?? They both sound like, well, part of Pink Floyd - although certain elements are missing from both pieces

I guess you could say The Final Cut is too much of Roger -- and that The Division Bell just isn't enough of Roger - funny, huh

__________________
Someone desrves a pat on the back.

No Roger means no Floyd, in my opinion.

__________________
Juice it

bollocks.

Exactly. Everyone has their own preference.

__________________
Someone desrves a pat on the back.

I find those kinds of statements to be rediculous, almost to the point of laughing.

__________________
"Why be a man when you can be a success?"-Bertolt Brecht

both are floydian in there own respect. I mean, they were made by the floyd and they have there own distinct sound. i wouldnt say either are less floydian. I love both and it will never change

__________________
"I like to think that oysters transcend national barriers"
"Ashes and diamonds, foe and friend, we were all equal in the end"
"...So much behind us...still far to go...still far to go..."
April 5, 2006 was amazing

The answer depends on who you think but the pink in floyd. The Gilmourians will say TFC is less floydlike, and versa visa for the Waters fans. I personally think the real floyd died with Animals, though most of what they did after that still kicked ass (I hate the Division Bell), it really wasn't them any more. It was just Rog, Dave, and their egos.

__________________
But I keep on comin' here, standing in this state. Well I'm always reasured the situation's gettin' carried away...

My dad would agree with you. Then again, he thinks Jimi Page plays too many solos.

__________________
But I keep on comin' here, standing in this state. Well I'm always reasured the situation's gettin' carried away...

i like this dad of yours.

I don't think either album is less Floyd like. Regardless of who was in the band, both albums were released under the name Pink Floyd and thus made it their sound at that point in time. I enjoy both albums, but The Final Cut is brilliant from start to finish.

if ya wanna get real pc, TDB is less floyd like because it was missing Roger waters intirely. However I like TDB alot more than TFC because gilmour is just a genious. But I do agree that TFC is a masterpiece

__________________
Evidence it once exist
At some point in time
But with no visible proof
It was ever really there...

I hear cries of blasphemy from all sides, but personally TDB is my favourite floyd album, while TFC is the worst.

TFC is a lot less floyd-like. simple as that.

__________________
Is there anybody out there?