What would you put on your 'Echoes Disc 3'???

I thought they did very well on Echoes, but I'd put:

Coming Back to Life
The Final Cut
Two Suns in the Sunset
Terminal Frost
Welcome to the Machine
Young Lust
In the Flesh?

_________________
Tear down The Wall!

__________________
"This Roman Meal Bakery though you might like to know . . ."

- The last words of Pink's second television set

My only complaint of echoes is that the decided to skip all of the albums between SoS and Meddle. Plus they skipped Obscured. Is it too much to ask that they at least put one song from every album on a compilation disc. Let's think...Cymbaline, Fat Old Sun, If, or even Narrow Way Part 3.

Apparently it was.

__________________
Sharp-distance

I agree with you. It's great, but if I could change one thing I'd take off The Great Gig in the Sky. I don't think that's one of their "best"

And Run Like Hell.

__________________
"This Roman Meal Bakery though you might like to know . . ."

- The last words of Pink's second television set

Since I didn't buy Echoes, I'll just put together all the best songs I want on one disc.

When the Tigers Broke Free
The Thin Ice
The Gunner's Dream
Mother
What Shall We Do Now?/Empty Spaces
Young Lust
Not Now John
One of My Turns
Fletcher Memorial Home
Is There Anybody Out There?
Wish You Were Here
Us & Them
Comfortably Numb
The Final Cut

And I thought that I was a big Roger fan!

Cheers,

Mark

__________________
And you my love, won't you take my hand
We'll go back in time,
To that mystic land
Where the dew drops cry, and the cats meow
I will take you there
I will show you how....

This is gonna be tricky...

(1)The Embryo (live on bbc w/o audience)
(2)Saucerful of Secrets (pompeii)
(3)Fat Old Sun
(4)Stay
(5)Paintbox
(6)Summer '68
(7)Careful With That Axe Eugene (pompeii)
A Pillow Of Winds
(9)Wots uh the Deal
(10)Mudmen
(11)If
(12)The Narrow Way (all)
(13)Cirrus Minor

I know its all classic stuff, but g'damnit, this is the way I'd have it...the TRUE Floyd sound.

__________________
"I open the door, to an empty room, then I forget."

My First Post, Anyway I just made this tonight-Echoes 3:
1. Chilhood's End
2. Young Lust
3. Candy and A Currant Bun
4. Fearless
5. On The Turning Away (Barely made it)
6. Pigs on the Wing (Combined Version)
7. Pigs (3 Differerent Ones)
8. Have A Cigar
9. What Do You Want From Me
10. Fat Old Sun
11. Not Now John
12. Mother
13. Brain Damage/Eclipse
What do you all think?

__________________
There'll be war and There'll be peace, but everthing one day will cease. All the iron turned to rust, all the proud men turned to dust.

My First Post, Anyway I just made this tonight-Echoes 3:
1. Chilhood's End
2. Young Lust
3. Candy and A Currant Bun
4. Fearless
5. On The Turning Away (Barely made it)
6. Pigs on the Wing (Combined Version)
7. Pigs (3 Differerent Ones)
8. Have A Cigar
9. What Do You Want From Me
10. Fat Old Sun
11. Not Now John
12. Mother
13. Brain Damage/Eclipse
What do you all think?

__________________
There'll be war and There'll be peace, but everthing one day will cease. All the iron turned to rust, all the proud men turned to dust.

pretty good

__________________
I pity the fool who don't like the Floyd.

IMHO, I think they should have put all of their long tracks on one CD, Like Echoes and SOYCD, Not edit them, and use instrumentals as fillers on whatever room was left over.

I just hate listening to Hey You after finishing an epic like Echoes.

__________________
stchrissie is not me.

That's why I don't listen to compilation discs.

__________________
is snuggly

echoes disc three 'eh

Outside the wall
a great day for freedom
south hampton dock
final cut
not now john
fat old sun
mother
if
is there anybody out there
pigs (three different ones)
summer '69
a saucerful of secrets
atom heart mother
corperal clegg
let there be more light
high hopes
vegetable man

i didn't buy echoes because i have everything else, but i don't believe those songs would be on it because they aren't "Popular" it's a shame how quality is weeded out to meet the standard of tiny boppers and dimwits who think the only three albums floyd released were DSOM WYWH and the wall... so, tell me what ya think of my list, i'm MystaR PINK on Aim

__________________
Eric Buchinski

Disc 3:

01: Free Four
02: Speak To Me / B
03: Vera
04: Nobody Home
05: The Gnome
06: Take It Back
07: On The Turning Away
08: Brain Damage / E
09: Pigs (3 Different Ones)
10: The Gunners Dream
11: Run Like Hell
12: What uh...
13: Waiting On The Worms

__________________
"And The Worms Ate Into His Brain..."

All the songs I felt that were missing:

Young Lust
The Final Cut
Not Now John
Two Suns in the Sunset
Cymbaline
Dogs
Welcome to the Machine
Breathe
Any Colour You Like
Brain Damage/Eclipse
Narrow Way Part 3
Green is the Colour
Fearless

I should of said "All the ones that are my personal favorites" They aren't the best songs.

__________________
Sharp-distance