What would you put on your 'Echoes Disc 3'???

What would you put on your 'Echoes Disc 3'??? Only twenty songs, here's mine. You can even mark a star beside the ones you think shouldve been on the original echoes.

interstellar overdrive
the scarecrow
*a saucerful of secrets
corporal clegg
the narrow way
if
*summer 68
*atom heart mother
fearless
brain damage/eclipse
have a cigar
welcome to the machine
*pigs(three different ones)
dogs
younglust
goodbye blue sky
*the final cut
*not now john
the gunners dream
coming back to life

i just rececntly made a floyd mix this is what it had:

Biding My Time
Atom Heart Mother
Shine On (parts 1-5)
Shine On (parts 6-9)
A Spanish Peice
Echoes

I had all these songs on cds already i just wanted a mix with the three really long songs on it (AHM, Shine on, echoes). the only reason i put a spanish peice on there is cuz i only had a little over a min. left on the cd and that fit cuz its only like 1:05.

peace

ps. im bored, IM me on AIM, please

*welcome to the machine
let there be more light
lucifer sam
*interstellar overdrive
remember a day
atom heart mother
*if
summer of '68
cirus minor
*careful with that axe eugene (live Umm..Ver)
obscured by clouds
brain damage/eclipse
have a cigar
*dogs
*pigs
*what shall we do now? (studio ver.)
empty spaces
young lust
2 suns in the sunset
terminal frost

yeah, i could make a list of songs i would have wanted to see on echoes, but that might take a while and defeat the purpose of a "best of" cuz it would be more or less, every song.

I Would Put:

DISC 3
Fearless
Dogs
Run Like Hell
Have A Cigar
Brain Damage/Eclipse
Summer 68
Let There Be More Light
A Saucerful Of Secrets
On The Turning Away
What Do You Want From Me
Mother
Young Lust

DISC 4
Free Four
Breathe In The Air
Welcome To The Machine
Fat Old Sun
Apples & Oranges
Careful With That Axe, Eugine
Pigs On The Wing (Complete, Snowy White Solo)
In The Flesh
Intersteller Overdrive
Poles Apart
Pigs (Three Different Ones)
Not Now John

I was just sitting here wondering the same thing when I saw this forum. You guys gave me alot of ideas and I'll post back with what I came up with. I might have missed it but did anyone remember the Gilmour classic Childhood's End? Also, where o where can I find a copy of Apples and Oranges? Or just for shits and giggles, anyone know where a "Vegetable Man" download might be? Always wanted to hear those songs but never have. Thanks!

childhood's end is my favorite song on OBC

You can get Vegetable Man alomst anywhere on the net, its really not that hard to find.

cheers

Welcome to the Machine
Fearless
Have a Cigar
Pillow of Wind
Childhoods End
Crumbling land

any track from the "Man and the Journey"

Mother
any other track from OBC
Run Like Hell

I haven't heard anything from the "More" sountrack except the Nile Song, so maby that too...

oh yeah... and the 8 track version of Pigs on the Wing
:smile:

Echoes - Disc 3

Interstellar Overdrive
Lucifer Sam
A Saucerful Of Secrets
Summer '68
Brain Damage
Eclipse
Welcome To The Machine
Dogs
Run Like Hell
The Trial
Not Now John
Atom Heart Mother
Fearless
Pigs
In The Flesh
The Final Cut

I can't think of any post-Waters songs to put on my Echoes...

ECHOES - DISC 3

In The Flesh ?
Fearless
Welcome To The Machine
Dogs
On The Turning Away
Coming Back To Life
Run Like Hell
Have A Cigar
What Do You Want From Me
Pigs (Three Different One)
Southamton Dock
Nobody Home
Poles Apart
Another Brick In The Wall (Part 1)
The Final Cut
Brain Damage / Eclipse

If you want to have it, you can record your own.

ECHOES - DISC 3

The Gnome
Pow R Toc H
Celestial Voices (studio)
Crying Song
Cymbaline
Careful with that Axe (ummagumma version)
Embryo
Country Song
If
Summer 68
Fearless
San Tropez
Wot's...Uh the deal
Stay
Absolutely Curtains
Brain Damage/Eclipse
Pigs on the wing (8 track full version)

ok, i finally bought echoes, just to add to collection. but afterwards i made an echoes disc 3:
1. interstellar overdrive *i edited it with a tape
2. run like hell
3. fearless
4. atom heart mother suite *edited
5. pigs (three different ones) *edited
6. summer 68
7. the scarecrow
8. a saucerful of secrets (celestial voices)*from live at pompeii
9. the narrow way pt 3
10. have a cigar
11. empty spaces
12. younglust
13. one slip
14. the final cut
15. not now john
16. on the turning away
17. pigs on the wing (8 track version)
18. brain damage
19. eclipse

i know i dont have some of the good ones, but i couldnt put everything. i didnt want all of dark side on both the echoes.

It's just too much good Pink Floyd in the world. I just want to say, I tried to make an Echoes: Disc 3

1. Speak To Me/Breathe
2. Welcome To The Machine
3. Have A Cigar
4. Wearing The Inside Out
5. What Do You Want From Me?
6. Goodbye Blue Sky
7. Is There Anybody Out There?
8. Nobody Home
9. In The Flesh?/The Thin Ice
10.The Gunner's Dream
11.The Final Cut
12.Not Now John