sinking island

i have had the new album "on an island" from the day of it's release. I haven't
seen it printed yet but i will say it now, this album is weak, weak, WEAK. I listened to this album for about 4 days straight at work when i first got it, and my first thought was, "can I get my money back for this". I decided to give it one more try today at work and I still think the same way. I hope you all don't ask for my APFFN membership card back, but i can't help thinking that if this album didn't have David Gilmour's name on it it wouldn't sell 100,000 copies. There is some good guitar on here, but it doesn't carry the album, and most of the songs are very ho-hum. Is this just me or are there more people out there with the same feeling?

It's good for watching holiday programmes to. And bowls.

I like it well it is relaxing . When I go to sleep I put it on.

I put it on when I am asleep.

It's half a year since its release and still I listen to it every day. A great album!

For travel shows. And bowls.

As with AMLOR, DSOT, TDB and PULSE, this album was bought for me and after the first hearing, I haven't played it since. It is very weak.

Keep your APFFN card as there's nought wrong with you...IMHO.

There's some lame shit on it, fer shur.

A couple of decent tracks, but Dave going on about the wife and kids and walks in the woods don't do it for me.

I forgot to say I do homework and study while listening to this.

So does Dave, I think.

I like it mostly but there are some lame ones but i also fall asleep to it. Dave at middle age what do you expect? Another Pompeii would be great but that time has passed.

I'm starting to believe all of you are a bunch a bunch of teenagers who is listening to Heavy Metal and Hip Hop all the time. METALLICA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

take a breath and this heaven are up there with the best. some other great tracks and a few boring ones but overall a good album and yes i also agree gd to go sleep to

Believe what you will. It doesn't change the fact some of us Floyd fans find BDG's latest solo offering as nothing less than sub-standard.

We are, as you, entitled to hold the opinions we do without being judged or dismissed by the less than discerning fans of BDG's solo fartstorms.

Maybe your problem is listen at work.